Controlled Environment Farming
Controlled Environment Farming Market Segments - by Type (Indoor Farming, Vertical Farming, Greenhouse Farming, Aquaponics, Aeroponics), Crop Type (Fruits & Vegetables, Herbs & Microgreens, Flowers & Ornamentals), Equipment Type (HVAC Systems, LED Grow Lights, Sensors, Irrigation Systems, Control Systems), Technology (Hydroponics, Aeroponics, Aquaponics, Soil-based), and Region (North America, Europe, Asia Pacific, Latin America, Middle East & Africa) - Global Industry Analysis, Growth, Share, Size, Trends, and Forecast 2025-2035
- Report Preview
- Table Of Content
- Segments
- Methodology
Controlled Environment Farming Market Outlook
The global controlled environment farming market is poised to experience significant growth, projected to reach approximately USD 9.8 billion by 2035, at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of around 12.3% during the forecast period from 2025 to 2035. This growth can be attributed to several factors, including the increasing global population, the rise in urbanization, and a growing emphasis on sustainable agricultural practices. Controlled environment farming (CEF) systems offer an innovative solution to address food security challenges by maximizing crop yields while utilizing minimal land and water resources. Additionally, advancements in technology, such as automation and improved climate control systems, are making CEF more efficient and cost-effective. Furthermore, the growing awareness of the health and environmental benefits of locally grown produce is also propelling the demand for controlled environment farming solutions.
Growth Factor of the Market
The growth of the controlled environment farming market is driven by a combination of technological advancements and the increasing need for food production that is both sustainable and efficient. Urbanization is leading to a decrease in arable land, pushing agricultural innovations like CEF to the forefront as viable solutions to meet the food demands of growing populations. Additionally, climate change is impacting traditional farming methods, making controlled environments an attractive alternative that can provide stable conditions for crop production year-round. The COVID-19 pandemic has also heightened interest in local food production, as supply chain disruptions highlighted the vulnerabilities in traditional agricultural models. Moreover, government initiatives and investments aimed at promoting sustainable agriculture are further enhancing market growth, creating a more favorable environment for controlled environment farming technologies.
Key Highlights of the Market
- The market is projected to grow at a CAGR of 12.3% from 2025 to 2035.
- Indoor farming and vertical farming are experiencing the highest adoption rates.
- The demand for fresh produce in urban areas is driving market expansion.
- Technological advancements are making CEF systems more efficient and cost-effective.
- Government initiatives promoting sustainable agriculture are boosting market opportunities.
By Type
Indoor Farming:
Indoor farming is one of the fastest-growing segments within the controlled environment farming market, enabling the cultivation of crops in a controlled space, irrespective of external weather conditions. By utilizing advanced technologies such as hydroponics, aeroponics, and LED lighting systems, indoor farms can produce a variety of crops year-round. The increased demand for fresh produce, especially in urban areas, has significantly contributed to the rise of indoor farming. Additionally, the ability to reduce water usage and eliminate the need for pesticides and herbicides makes indoor farming a more sustainable choice. Moreover, the customization of grow environments allows for the optimization of plant health and yield, further enhancing its appeal to growers and investors alike.
Vertical Farming:
Vertical farming is another innovative approach that maximizes space utilization by stacking layers of crops in a controlled environment, often within urban settings. This method not only allows for large-scale production in minimal land area but also minimizes transportation costs and emissions, as fresh produce can be grown in proximity to consumers. Vertical farms often utilize advanced technologies such as automated systems for monitoring and maintaining optimal growth conditions, thereby increasing efficiency. As a result, vertical farming is gaining traction among farmers and investors, particularly in metropolitan areas where land is scarce. The segment is characterized by its high potential for scalability, making it an attractive investment opportunity.
Greenhouse Farming:
Greenhouse farming utilizes transparent structures to create a controlled environment for growing crops, combining natural sunlight with technology to optimize growth conditions. This method allows farmers to extend the growing season and produce crops that would not thrive in the local climate. Greenhouses are often equipped with automated climate control systems, irrigation systems, and sensors to monitor environmental conditions. The versatility of greenhouse farming makes it suitable for a wide variety of crops, from vegetables to flowers. Moreover, as consumer preferences shift towards fresh and locally grown produce, greenhouse farming is positioned to meet rising demand while also adhering to sustainable practices.
Aquaponics:
Aquaponics is a sustainable farming method that combines aquaculture (raising fish) with hydroponics (growing plants without soil) in a symbiotic environment. In this system, fish waste provides an organic nutrient source for the plants, while the plants help to filter and purify the water for the fish. This method not only maximizes resource efficiency by utilizing water and nutrients effectively, but it also reduces the need for chemical fertilizers. The growing interest in sustainable food sources and organic produce is driving the adoption of aquaponics systems, making it a noteworthy segment within the controlled environment farming market. Its ability to produce both fish and vegetables simultaneously presents a unique opportunity for diversified farming operations.
Aeroponics:
Aeroponics is a soilless growing technique that involves suspending plant roots in an air or mist environment and providing nutrients directly to the roots through a mist of nutrient-rich water. This method requires significantly less water and space than traditional farming methods, making it an efficient choice for urban agriculture. Aeroponics systems are often used for growing high-value crops, such as lettuce, herbs, and strawberries, where market demand is high. The reduced risk of pests and diseases in a controlled environment further enhances the appeal of aeroponics, as it allows for healthier crop production without the need for pesticides. As urban populations continue to grow, the adoption of aeroponics is expected to increase significantly.
By Crop Type
Fruits & Vegetables:
The fruits and vegetables segment is a major contributor to the controlled environment farming market, driven by the increasing demand for fresh produce among consumers. Growing fruits and vegetables in controlled environments allows for year-round production, which is particularly advantageous in regions with harsh climates or limited agricultural land. This segment benefits from advancements in growing technologies, including hydroponics and vertical farming systems that optimize space and yield. Moreover, the shift in consumer preferences towards organic and locally sourced produce is further propelling investments in this segment, as controlled environment farming provides a sustainable solution to meet these demands.
Herbs & Microgreens:
Herbs and microgreens are gaining popularity in the controlled environment farming market due to their high market value and lucrative growth potential. These crops can be grown in compact spaces, making them ideal candidates for indoor and vertical farming systems. The quick growth cycle of herbs and microgreens allows for rapid turnover and continuous production, contributing to higher profit margins for growers. Furthermore, the increasing health consciousness among consumers and the demand for fresh culinary ingredients are driving the growth of this segment. The ability to produce herbs and microgreens without pesticides in controlled environments enhances their appeal, as consumers are increasingly seeking clean and healthy food options.
Flowers & Ornamentals:
This segment includes the cultivation of various flowers and ornamental plants, which are increasingly being produced in controlled environments to meet consistent market demand. Controlled environment farming allows for precise control over growing conditions, leading to high-quality blooms and ornamental plants throughout the year. The floral industry is characterized by seasonal demand spikes, and utilizing controlled environments helps growers to prepare for peak sales periods by ensuring availability of products regardless of external factors. Moreover, as the trend towards sustainable and eco-friendly products rises, controlled environments provide a means to produce ornamental plants with reduced resource consumption, appealing to environmentally conscious consumers.
By Equipment Type
HVAC Systems:
HVAC systems play a crucial role in controlled environment farming by maintaining optimal temperature and humidity levels for plant growth. These systems are designed to create a stable and conducive environment, ensuring that crops receive the necessary climate conditions to thrive. The growing adoption of advanced HVAC technologies, including energy-efficient solutions, is driving market growth as farmers seek to minimize operational costs while maximizing crop yields. Additionally, the integration of smart technology into HVAC systems allows for remote monitoring and control, enhancing the efficiency and effectiveness of these systems in controlled farming operations.
LED Grow Lights:
LED grow lights are essential for providing the necessary light spectrum for photosynthesis in controlled environment farming. These energy-efficient lighting solutions have become increasingly popular due to their ability to produce specific wavelengths of light that optimize plant growth and yield. The use of LED grow lights reduces energy consumption significantly compared to traditional lighting systems, making them a cost-effective choice for growers. As the demand for year-round crop production continues to rise, the adoption of LED grow lights is expected to grow, further fueling the controlled environment farming market.
Sensors:
Sensors are integral to controlled environment farming, enabling precise monitoring and management of growing conditions. They play a vital role in tracking parameters such as temperature, humidity, light levels, and nutrient concentrations, allowing for real-time adjustments to optimize plant growth. The increasing adoption of IoT technologies has further enhanced the capabilities of sensor systems, leading to improved data collection and analysis for better decision-making. As growers continuously seek ways to increase efficiency and reduce costs, the demand for advanced sensor technologies is anticipated to rise, strengthening the overall market landscape.
Irrigation Systems:
Irrigation systems are essential for ensuring that crops receive adequate water in controlled environment farming. These systems can be tailored to meet the specific needs of various crops while conserving water resources. Techniques such as drip irrigation and automated watering systems are increasingly being adopted to enhance efficiency and reduce waste. The rising need for sustainable agricultural practices is driving innovation in irrigation technologies, making them more efficient and effective. With the global emphasis on water conservation and efficient resource use, the demand for advanced irrigation systems in controlled environment farming is expected to grow significantly.
Control Systems:
Control systems are vital for managing and automating various aspects of controlled environment farming. These systems utilize advanced software and algorithms to regulate environmental conditions such as temperature, humidity, light intensity, and nutrient delivery. By automating these processes, control systems help to minimize human error, improve operational efficiency, and enhance crop yields. As technology continues to evolve, the integration of artificial intelligence and machine learning into control systems is expected to revolutionize the way controlled environment farming is conducted. This advancement will lead to more precise and adaptive farming practices, catering to the specific needs of different crops and ensuring optimal growth conditions.
By Technology
Hydroponics:
Hydroponics is a widely adopted technology in controlled environment farming that involves growing plants in nutrient-rich water instead of soil. This method allows for precise control over nutrient delivery, resulting in faster growth and higher yields compared to traditional soil-based methods. Hydroponics systems can be fully automated, minimizing labor costs and maximizing efficiency. The rising consumer demand for fresh vegetables and herbs is driving the growth of hydroponic farming, as it provides a sustainable solution to food production that can be implemented in urban areas with limited space. The increasing awareness of the environmental benefits associated with hydroponics, such as reduced water usage and lower pesticide application, further enhances its market appeal.
Aeroponics:
Aeroponics is an innovative soilless growing technique that uses mist or air to deliver nutrients and water directly to plant roots. This technology offers several advantages, including reduced water usage and faster plant growth rates. Aeroponics systems are particularly effective for growing high-value crops, such as leafy greens and herbs, as they provide optimal conditions for root development and nutrient absorption. The ability to grow crops in a compact, vertical arrangement makes aeroponics ideal for urban farming environments where space is limited. As the demand for fresh, pesticide-free produce continues to rise, aeroponics is becoming an increasingly popular choice among growers.
Aquaponics:
Aquaponics combines aquaculture and hydroponics to create a sustainable farming ecosystem where fish and plants coexist and benefit from each other's growth. In this system, fish waste provides the nutrients needed for plant growth, while plants help to purify the water for the fish. This closed-loop system significantly reduces water consumption compared to traditional farming methods and generates high-quality, organic produce. The increasing consumer preference for sustainable and locally sourced food is driving the growth of aquaponics as a viable agricultural method. Furthermore, aquaponics systems can be customized to suit various crop types and fish species, making it a flexible and adaptable solution for controlled environment farming.
Soil-based:
Although soil-based farming is traditionally associated with outdoor agriculture, advancements in controlled environment farming have also enabled soil-based cultivation within greenhouses and indoor farms. In these controlled settings, soil can be managed more effectively, allowing for optimal nutrient delivery and moisture retention. Soil-based systems offer various benefits, including the ability to grow a wide range of crops and the natural microbial activity that enhances plant health. As consumer preferences shift towards organic and naturally grown produce, soil-based controlled environment farming provides an appealing option that meets these demands while ensuring sustainable and productive agricultural practices.
By Region
The controlled environment farming market exhibits distinct regional characteristics, each contributing to the overall growth of the industry. North America represents one of the largest markets, driven by technological advancements and increasing investments in urban agriculture solutions. The region is projected to reach a market value of approximately USD 3.2 billion by 2035, with a CAGR of 13.5% from 2025 to 2035. The United States stands out as a leader in controlled environment farming, with a significant number of indoor farms and vertical farming operations emerging in urban areas. Meanwhile, Europe is also witnessing considerable growth, particularly in countries like the Netherlands and Germany, which are known for their innovative agricultural practices. The European controlled environment farming market is expected to grow at a CAGR of around 11.7%, reaching approximately USD 2.6 billion by 2035.
In the Asia Pacific region, the market is experiencing rapid growth, primarily due to increasing urbanization and rising food demand. Countries like Japan, China, and Singapore are leading the way in adopting controlled environment farming technologies to address food security challenges. The Asia Pacific market is projected to reach USD 2.8 billion by 2035, showcasing a CAGR of around 12.8% during the forecast period. Latin America and the Middle East & Africa are also emerging markets, with growing interest in sustainable farming practices and investments in agricultural technologies. While these regions currently represent a smaller share of the overall market, their potential for growth is significant, particularly as awareness of controlled environment farming benefits continues to rise.
Opportunities
As the global emphasis on sustainable agriculture intensifies, the controlled environment farming market presents numerous opportunities for innovation and growth. One of the most significant opportunities lies in the expansion of urban agriculture, where controlled environment farming can address food production challenges in densely populated areas. The increasing consumer demand for fresh, organic produce is driving investment in indoor and vertical farming systems that can be implemented in urban settings. Furthermore, advancements in technology are enabling growers to optimize their operations through data-driven decision-making, leading to improved yields and cost efficiencies. As governments and organizations worldwide continue to prioritize food security and sustainability, partnerships and collaborations within the controlled environment farming sector are also expected to rise, fostering growth and development.
Another substantial opportunity exists in the integration of smart technologies and automation within controlled environment farming. The adoption of IoT devices, artificial intelligence, and machine learning can enhance monitoring and management capabilities, allowing growers to respond promptly to changes in environmental conditions. This increased efficiency can lead to reduced operational costs and higher profit margins. Moreover, the development of modular and scalable controlled environment farming solutions offers additional opportunities for growth, as these systems can be tailored to meet the specific needs of various markets and consumers. As research and development efforts continue to evolve, the potential for innovative solutions and technologies in controlled environment farming remains vast, promising a dynamic future for the industry.
Threats
Despite the promising outlook for the controlled environment farming market, several threats could hinder its growth. One major concern is the high initial investment and operational costs associated with implementing controlled environment farming systems. For many new entrants, the financial burden of acquiring advanced technology, infrastructure, and skilled labor can be a significant barrier to entry. Additionally, fluctuations in energy prices can impact operational costs, especially for energy-intensive systems such as indoor farming and vertical farming facilities. As energy efficiency and sustainability become increasingly critical, these financial challenges may deter potential investors and limit market expansion.
Another threat to the controlled environment farming market is the potential for technological obsolescence. Rapid advancements in agricultural technology mean that growers must continuously adapt and upgrade their systems to remain competitive. This need for ongoing investment in new technologies can strain resources and lead to uncertainties in long-term growth prospects. Furthermore, the market may face competition from traditional agricultural practices that are perceived as more straightforward or cost-effective. Consumers may also exhibit resistance to adopting new farming methods or products, particularly if they are not well-informed about the benefits of controlled environment farming. Educating consumers and building trust in these innovative agricultural practices will be pivotal in combating these threats.
Competitor Outlook
- AeroFarms
- Gotham Greens
- Plenty
- BrightFarms
- Bowery Farming
- Green Spirit Farms
- Freight Farms
- Farm.One
- Crop One Holdings
- Urban Crop Solutions
- Sky Greens
- Pure Harvest Smart Farms
- AgriCool
- Smart Greenhouse
- Hydroponic Farms
The competitive landscape of the controlled environment farming market is becoming increasingly dynamic, as a growing number of companies enter the space with innovative solutions and technologies. Established players are leveraging their expertise and resources to enhance operational efficiencies and expand their product offerings. Many companies are forming strategic partnerships and collaborations to strengthen their market presence and broaden their technological capabilities. As competition intensifies, companies are focusing on differentiation through unique growing methods, product quality, and customer engagement strategies. For instance, firms like AeroFarms and Plenty are at the forefront of vertical farming, utilizing cutting-edge technology to optimize crop production and sustainability.
Major companies in the controlled environment farming market are continuously investing in research and development to enhance their offerings and capitalize on emerging trends. For example, Gotham Greens, known for its hydroponic greenhouses, emphasizes sustainable production techniques and locally sourced products to meet rising consumer demand. BrightFarms is another prominent player that partners with supermarkets to provide fresh, locally grown produce, reducing the carbon footprint associated with transportation. Additionally, Bowery Farming has gained recognition for its innovative use of technology in indoor farming, allowing for year-round crop production and minimal resource consumption. These companies exemplify the competitive nature of the market and the ongoing drive for innovation.
As the market evolves, the emergence of new players continues to reshape the competitive landscape. Start-ups like Farm.One and Crop One Holdings are gaining traction by offering specialized products and catering to niche markets. Urban Crop Solutions is focusing on modular farming systems that can be adapted to various settings, providing flexibility and scalability. These innovative approaches highlight the diverse strategies being employed by companies to capture market share and address the unique challenges of controlled environment farming. Overall, the competitive landscape is characterized by a blend of established companies and new entrants, all vying to shape the future of agriculture through sustainable and efficient practices.
1 Appendix
- 1.1 List of Tables
- 1.2 List of Figures
2 Introduction
- 2.1 Market Definition
- 2.2 Scope of the Report
- 2.3 Study Assumptions
- 2.4 Base Currency & Forecast Periods
3 Market Dynamics
- 3.1 Market Growth Factors
- 3.2 Economic & Global Events
- 3.3 Innovation Trends
- 3.4 Supply Chain Analysis
4 Consumer Behavior
- 4.1 Market Trends
- 4.2 Pricing Analysis
- 4.3 Buyer Insights
5 Key Player Profiles
- 5.1 Plenty
- 5.1.1 Business Overview
- 5.1.2 Products & Services
- 5.1.3 Financials
- 5.1.4 Recent Developments
- 5.1.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.2 AgriCool
- 5.2.1 Business Overview
- 5.2.2 Products & Services
- 5.2.3 Financials
- 5.2.4 Recent Developments
- 5.2.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.3 Farm.One
- 5.3.1 Business Overview
- 5.3.2 Products & Services
- 5.3.3 Financials
- 5.3.4 Recent Developments
- 5.3.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.4 AeroFarms
- 5.4.1 Business Overview
- 5.4.2 Products & Services
- 5.4.3 Financials
- 5.4.4 Recent Developments
- 5.4.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.5 Sky Greens
- 5.5.1 Business Overview
- 5.5.2 Products & Services
- 5.5.3 Financials
- 5.5.4 Recent Developments
- 5.5.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.6 BrightFarms
- 5.6.1 Business Overview
- 5.6.2 Products & Services
- 5.6.3 Financials
- 5.6.4 Recent Developments
- 5.6.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.7 Freight Farms
- 5.7.1 Business Overview
- 5.7.2 Products & Services
- 5.7.3 Financials
- 5.7.4 Recent Developments
- 5.7.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.8 Gotham Greens
- 5.8.1 Business Overview
- 5.8.2 Products & Services
- 5.8.3 Financials
- 5.8.4 Recent Developments
- 5.8.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.9 Bowery Farming
- 5.9.1 Business Overview
- 5.9.2 Products & Services
- 5.9.3 Financials
- 5.9.4 Recent Developments
- 5.9.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.10 Hydroponic Farms
- 5.10.1 Business Overview
- 5.10.2 Products & Services
- 5.10.3 Financials
- 5.10.4 Recent Developments
- 5.10.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.11 Smart Greenhouse
- 5.11.1 Business Overview
- 5.11.2 Products & Services
- 5.11.3 Financials
- 5.11.4 Recent Developments
- 5.11.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.12 Crop One Holdings
- 5.12.1 Business Overview
- 5.12.2 Products & Services
- 5.12.3 Financials
- 5.12.4 Recent Developments
- 5.12.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.13 Green Spirit Farms
- 5.13.1 Business Overview
- 5.13.2 Products & Services
- 5.13.3 Financials
- 5.13.4 Recent Developments
- 5.13.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.14 Urban Crop Solutions
- 5.14.1 Business Overview
- 5.14.2 Products & Services
- 5.14.3 Financials
- 5.14.4 Recent Developments
- 5.14.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.15 Pure Harvest Smart Farms
- 5.15.1 Business Overview
- 5.15.2 Products & Services
- 5.15.3 Financials
- 5.15.4 Recent Developments
- 5.15.5 SWOT Analysis
- 5.1 Plenty
6 Market Segmentation
- 6.1 Controlled Environment Farming Market, By Type
- 6.1.1 Indoor Farming
- 6.1.2 Vertical Farming
- 6.1.3 Greenhouse Farming
- 6.1.4 Aquaponics
- 6.1.5 Aeroponics
- 6.2 Controlled Environment Farming Market, By Crop Type
- 6.2.1 Fruits & Vegetables
- 6.2.2 Herbs & Microgreens
- 6.2.3 Flowers & Ornamentals
- 6.3 Controlled Environment Farming Market, By Technology
- 6.3.1 Hydroponics
- 6.3.2 Aeroponics
- 6.3.3 Aquaponics
- 6.3.4 Soil-based
- 6.1 Controlled Environment Farming Market, By Type
7 Competitive Analysis
- 7.1 Key Player Comparison
- 7.2 Market Share Analysis
- 7.3 Investment Trends
- 7.4 SWOT Analysis
8 Research Methodology
- 8.1 Analysis Design
- 8.2 Research Phases
- 8.3 Study Timeline
9 Future Market Outlook
- 9.1 Growth Forecast
- 9.2 Market Evolution
10 Geographical Overview
- 10.1 Europe - Market Analysis
- 10.1.1 By Country
- 10.1.1.1 UK
- 10.1.1.2 France
- 10.1.1.3 Germany
- 10.1.1.4 Spain
- 10.1.1.5 Italy
- 10.1.1 By Country
- 10.2 Asia Pacific - Market Analysis
- 10.2.1 By Country
- 10.2.1.1 India
- 10.2.1.2 China
- 10.2.1.3 Japan
- 10.2.1.4 South Korea
- 10.2.1 By Country
- 10.3 Latin America - Market Analysis
- 10.3.1 By Country
- 10.3.1.1 Brazil
- 10.3.1.2 Argentina
- 10.3.1.3 Mexico
- 10.3.1 By Country
- 10.4 North America - Market Analysis
- 10.4.1 By Country
- 10.4.1.1 USA
- 10.4.1.2 Canada
- 10.4.1 By Country
- 10.5 Middle East & Africa - Market Analysis
- 10.5.1 By Country
- 10.5.1.1 Middle East
- 10.5.1.2 Africa
- 10.5.1 By Country
- 10.6 Controlled Environment Farming Market by Region
- 10.1 Europe - Market Analysis
11 Global Economic Factors
- 11.1 Inflation Impact
- 11.2 Trade Policies
12 Technology & Innovation
- 12.1 Emerging Technologies
- 12.2 AI & Digital Trends
- 12.3 Patent Research
13 Investment & Market Growth
- 13.1 Funding Trends
- 13.2 Future Market Projections
14 Market Overview & Key Insights
- 14.1 Executive Summary
- 14.2 Key Trends
- 14.3 Market Challenges
- 14.4 Regulatory Landscape
Segments Analyzed in the Report
The global Controlled Environment Farming market is categorized based on
By Type
- Indoor Farming
- Vertical Farming
- Greenhouse Farming
- Aquaponics
- Aeroponics
By Crop Type
- Fruits & Vegetables
- Herbs & Microgreens
- Flowers & Ornamentals
By Technology
- Hydroponics
- Aeroponics
- Aquaponics
- Soil-based
By Region
- North America
- Europe
- Asia Pacific
- Latin America
- Middle East & Africa
Key Players
- AeroFarms
- Gotham Greens
- Plenty
- BrightFarms
- Bowery Farming
- Green Spirit Farms
- Freight Farms
- Farm.One
- Crop One Holdings
- Urban Crop Solutions
- Sky Greens
- Pure Harvest Smart Farms
- AgriCool
- Smart Greenhouse
- Hydroponic Farms
- Publish Date : Jan 20 ,2025
- Report ID : AG-22
- No. Of Pages : 100
- Format : |
- Ratings : 4.7 (99 Reviews)